Of everything on this site, one fact turns more people away than the rest combined: four bedrooms share one bathroom. In both buildings, in every suite, with no upgrade, no premium option and no exception.

We keep putting that sentence in other posts and then moving on. It deserves a page of its own, because for some people it is a dealbreaker and they should find that out now rather than in October.

A suite bathroom at Garneau Towers

One of these per four bedrooms. This is the configuration, not an example of the cheapest one.

What four-to-one actually looks like

The honest version, not the brochure version.

On a weekday morning the constraint is not the whole day, it is roughly 7:30 to 9:00. Four people, one room. In practice suites sort this out within about a fortnight, usually without discussing it — people’s start times differ more than they expect, and the ones that clash adjust by fifteen minutes.

When it is genuinely hard: four people with the same 9am, in exam season, or when someone is ill. Those weeks are harder than living alone, and no amount of framing changes that.

When it is a non-issue: evenings, weekends, and any day where the four start times are spread across more than an hour — which is most of them, partly because we place on year of study and programme, and timetables cluster by both.

Why there is no upgrade path

Because it is the building, not the pricing.

Both buildings are laid out as four-bedroom suites with one bathroom. There is no two-bathroom suite to sell you, no en-suite room held back for people who pay more. The dearest room we let — Deluxe at University Tower, $880 every four weeks — shares a bathroom with three other bedrooms, exactly like the $560 Flex Basic.

So the price difference between our rooms buys floor area, a balcony, or two minutes’ walk. It never buys a private bathroom. If a listing elsewhere suggests one of our rooms has one, it is describing somewhere else.

What the ratio buys you

This is the trade, stated plainly: the shared bathroom is a substantial part of why the rent is what it is.

A self-contained studio gives you a private bathroom and your own kitchen, and costs accordingly — plus every utility in your name and all the furniture yours to buy. Our $560 to $880 every four weeks, with heat, water, power, Wi-Fi, furniture, laundry and maintenance included, exists on the other side of that trade.

Neither is better. They are different products at different prices, and the bathroom is the main thing separating them. The three arrangements compared.

How to decide, honestly

Three questions that settle it faster than deliberating.

1. Have you shared a bathroom before, with roughly this many people? Family homes often run four-to-one. If that was fine, this will probably be fine.

2. Is your morning fixed or flexible? A placement that starts at 7am sharp every day, in a suite of four, is the hardest version of this. If your timetable has give in it, the constraint mostly disappears.

3. Would you pay meaningfully more to avoid it? If yes, you want a studio, and we would rather you went and got one than signed a nine-month lease resenting the arrangement.

What to check on a viewing

Do not just look at it — look at it with the number in mind.

  • Run the shower. Pressure, and how long the hot water takes.
  • Then ask yourself what that means as the third person at 8:10.
  • Check whether there is storage in there for four people’s things, or whether everyone carries a wash bag back and forth.
  • Look at where the bathroom sits relative to the bedrooms — a bathroom off a hallway is a different experience from one you reach through a shared living space.

The full in-person checklist is here.

If the answer is no

Then it is no, and that is a useful outcome from reading a web page.

Who coliving suits — and who should not choose it lists the other cases where we are the wrong answer: pets, choosing your own suitemates, terms shorter than nine months outside June to August, and budgets under $560 every four weeks.

If the answer is yes, or probably, the rest of the decision is the walk and the room — and both buildings are here.